American neurologist David Perlmutter, who declared all grains to be enemies of humanity and health: Who is he?

This is the first book you'll come across when you scour the American science literature for Perlmutter's brain-bending "miracle" (he always says so) recipes: "Grain Brain," published in 2013 and #1 on the New York Times bestseller list.

Synopsis of the book

Dr. Perlmutter set out from the fact that the cause of brain defects such as Alzheimer's, which hundreds of thousands of people suffer from in our age, cannot be solely due to genetic factors, and that we need to examine environmental factors as well. Then, when he put together the experiences of the patients he treated and the research of his colleagues around the world, he saw that there is a very close relationship between diabetes and Alzheimer's. In fact, diabetes doubles the risk of Alzheimer's. Because, in fact, the same thing (nutrition) triggers both.

On the other hand, in individuals who remove the gluten, sugar and carbohydrate trio from their lives, attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder, anxiety and chronic stress, chronic headaches and migraine, depression, sugar, epilepsy, focus and concentration problems, inflammatory problems such as arthritis, insomnia, celiac, gluten An improvement has been observed in complaints such as allergies and irritable bowel syndrome, precursors of Alzheimer's and cognitive problems, obesity, and Tourette's syndrome.

While the first part of the book describes the negative effects of grains and sugars on the body in a very convincing way, the second part is a recipe for getting rid of these effects.

David Perlmutter is a Naples, Florida–based American celebrity doctor and author. Perlmutter is the author of health books, and is known for advocating a functional and holistic approach toward treating brain disorders. Perlmutter serves as a medical advisor for The Dr. Oz Show and Men's Health. Perlmutter wrote the book Grain Brain, released in September 2013, promoting the concept that gluten causes neurological conditions, which became a bestseller.

Analyzes

According to mainstream American medical authorities, Perlmutter's recommendations are not based on adequately researched and proven facts. His specialty is neurology, and therefore nutritional criteria for brain health, but none of his findings appear in scientific publications with research evidence. His contribution to highly influential and prestigious publications such as the "Journal of the American Medical Association" (JAMA) consists of letters to the editor. There are no references to his works. He has two large-scale studies published, which are directly related to neurology, far from today's nutrition and microbiome theories. Forty years ago, his mentor, Dr. Co-authored works with Albert Rhoton.

IS THIS THE LIFE POLICY?

“The promise of a single, simple cure for a wide variety of diseases and symptoms reminds us of the elixir of life traders in ancient times,” says a commentary in the “American Journal of Cardiology” regarding the book “Grain Brain.” In addition, the propositions in "Grain Brain" are not compatible with the current neurological literature. For example, the effect of a Mediterranean-style diet, including whole-grain foods, against Alzheimer's has been proven by experiments. David Katz, a Yale University nutritionist, also counts the arguments put forward in “Grain Brain” as a pop culture memorization; "Whole wheat doesn't make us fat, whole grains don't make us stupid," he says.

Defining gluten as a "hidden microbe", Perlmutter's book "Brain and Gut", originally called "Brain Maker", says that gluten-free nutrition, probiotics and fermented foods help protect against a range of diseases, from allergies and autism to Alzheimer's, ALS, dementia, Parkinson's and cancer. possible to protect. He says he works miracles with this diet. "It's silly to think that a gluten-free diet and probiotics will provide resistance to all these diseases," says microbiome expert Jonathan Eisen of the University of California. Eisen, who claims that the miracle cases announced by Perlmutter on his website do not have scientific credibility, likens Perlmutter to "charlatans selling the elixir of life".

Perlmutter doesn't sell the "elixir of life", but markets a variety of detox products and services and other supplements on its own websites. There's coconut oil for brain boosting (especially recommended for vegans), a $90 benefit pack for teens looking to boost their mental capacity, and even organic soap. Perlmutter has a brain detox cure for $8500; The program also included healing shamanic ceremonies.

There may also be envy over popular success in the interpretations of American medical authorities, unknown. But shouldn't it be considered at least as much as Perlmutter's prescriptions? Because the achievements that were applauded for a period can turn into a disgrace later on. For example The Andrew Wakefield case broke new ground for the "mumps-measles-rubella vaccine" (MMP) that is administered to tens of millions of children around the world, with the claim that "it can cause autism", but with negative results. When research published in the prestigious science journal The Lancet in 1998 turned out to be bogus, the publication was withdrawn in 2010 and Dr. Wakefield was suspended from the profession.

However, the claim made at that time spread as it spread around the world, laying the groundwork for anti-vaccine campaigns. Maybe that charlatan is responsible for the measles epidemics seen in the USA, some European countries and Israel today.